MM77 Posted January 23, 2010 Report Posted January 23, 2010 Yes I realise this isnt an OSF topic But I still think some of you can help Here goes: I'm confused about what to buy basically. Definitely after an M3 and the question is whether to go for an E46 or E36 (or maybe even an E30). Something just tells me the E36 will be a hell of a lot more fun that an E46. And thats the key thing I look for in a car, the fun factor. The only real way I can describe my thoughts is in an E36 (or E30) you turn off the radio and throw the car sideways around the next corner. In an E46, you turn on the radio, get comfy in the leather seats and cruise on to work. So in a nutshell, the E46 will definitely be a better car but is it as fun? Thoughts?
Monkfish Posted January 23, 2010 Report Posted January 23, 2010 I had an E36 a few years ago and they're awesome cars. Avoid the DSG box on this age of car though, as it's like texting your nan and asking her to change gears for you.
5hane Posted January 23, 2010 Report Posted January 23, 2010 I know where a black E30 M3 evo is for sale Pm me
GJUK Posted January 23, 2010 Report Posted January 23, 2010 E30 has to look the best, that is all I know.
Tom Posted January 23, 2010 Report Posted January 23, 2010 Given the choice between an E36 and E46. E46 all day long! That engine won the engine of the year award for 8 consecutive years it a fantastic unit with excellent power delivery. Even the SMG boxes are good. I see what you mean about comfort/boredom factor but i disagree, they are hard work enough to keep you involved but if you want to drive miss daisy in it, it will let you do that too. (I work on them everyday) As a car I don't like the E36, some of them are good but most of them are tired. I think parts prices are pretty similar too (BMW) Drive a couple back to back and see what you think. Tom
MM77 Posted January 23, 2010 Author Report Posted January 23, 2010 Given the choice between an E36 and E46. E46 all day long! That engine won the engine of the year award for 8 consecutive years it a fantastic unit with excellent power delivery. Even the SMG boxes are good. I see what you mean about comfort/boredom factor but i disagree, they are hard work enough to keep you involved but if you want to drive miss daisy in it, it will let you do that too. (I work on them everyday) As a car I don't like the E36, some of them are good but most of them are tired. I think parts prices are pretty similar too (BMW) Drive a couple back to back and see what you think. Tom Thanks for that Tom. Mk2Jo mentioned your name actually as somebody I should be speaking to Pretty confident the E46 is the winner then. After all I have my OSF's for the track-day sideways action. Then the M3 is the ideal car to cruise to work in and then have a blast around the Black Mountains afterward Yep I think i've decided. Now where the hell am I getting the £ from
Tom Posted January 23, 2010 Report Posted January 23, 2010 I know of a smg, titan silver, black leather, 54 plate that i've looked after for a while for sale right now. He's been too lazy to advertise it and is going to come in to my dealer to get a trade price for it!!! He needs it gone by the 2nd Feb i think. probably take around 16k for it. Interested?
MM77 Posted January 23, 2010 Author Report Posted January 23, 2010 I know of a smg, titan silver, black leather, 54 plate that i've looked after for a while for sale right now.He's been too lazy to advertise it and is going to come in to my dealer to get a trade price for it!!! He needs it gone by the 2nd Feb i think. probably take around 16k for it. Interested? That sounds like my ideal spec.... Might be a few weeks too early though Will be looking to buy mid to late Feb unfortunately.
Grizzley Dell Posted January 23, 2010 Report Posted January 23, 2010 e30 all the way, by far the best of the 3 series. screaming 4 pot, arse happy. cant want for more than that. best built to. less crap in it.
moredoorAsh Posted January 23, 2010 Report Posted January 23, 2010 For me it would depend on the budget, would def go for the E46 if i could, would be more then happy in the E36 though. I've got an E36 2.8 at the moment although all this talk about M3's is making me think a change is due......
PIG Posted January 23, 2010 Report Posted January 23, 2010 e30 for sure,but exspensive now for a decent m3
jamesmk1 Posted January 23, 2010 Report Posted January 23, 2010 for looks i would say e30. but out of the 36 and 46 it has to be the e46 i have drove a lot of these and i love em, good all round car but i would buy a m5 e39
X-pack-Glyn Posted January 27, 2010 Report Posted January 27, 2010 all are good cars..but, to be honest there was only ever one propper M3 and thats the E30!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now