A lot of interesting comments and well thought out arguments. A lot of shite comments as well. As a Scot it's hard to see where Alex Salmond bases most of his claims as I just don't get them. I would like to see us staying in the UK as I see us failing with independence. The trouble is he is using the Commonwealth Games and the Ryder Cup to his advantage to the young and not so learned amongst us who have a vote! He is not a popular person to a lot of us but is it enough to secure a No vote? Hope so.