Jump to content

Recommended Posts

  • Admin
Posted

So, would you buy a written off vehicle or have you bought one in the past?

 

What do you check? What are the pros and cons? Obviously cheaper but is there a reason you should walk away from them?

 

Definition of Cat D is as follows:

 

A damaged vehicle which the insurer has decided not to repair, but which could be repaired and returned to the road.

 

Anyone any thoughts?

Posted

As above, if its a 20k car it obviously takes more damage to make it a Cat D than it would a 1k motor.

 

1k motor could be a dented door, 20k motor could have been a full vandal attack, smashed glass, paint stripped etc.

 

Suppose ideally you want to see 'before' pictures. I would buy one given the choice.

  • Admin
Posted

No not as yet but the car is only a few years old and would have been quite expensive new so I'm guessing the damage was quite extensive.

 

Edit: Just spoken to the seller and funny old thing, it allegedly was written off for damage to the front passenger door....................somehow I can't see a £20k 5 series estate being written off just because it needs a new door. He said it's immaculate and you can't see anything wrong with the car but I remain sceptical. What's more it's price is a little high given its history and above average miles...............then when questioned on the service history that didn't sound too great either.

 

So, plenty more fish in the sea......................but why are they all so far away!

  • Admin
Posted
My £28,000 525ise, would be a write off now if the paint got scrathed....

 

but then, it's 16 years old now and now worth less than the 12 month tax disk.

 

fair do's but I meant that the car is worth £20k now, with it's spec it was probably nearly £50k new.

 

And there are 30'000 reasons for never buying a new car if that's what they lose after only four years! :eeek::eeek::eeek:

Posted

I bought an 05 Focus in 2006 that was a Cat D, I think it must've had the engine out to repair it as it had a couple of things wrong with it (fan didn't come on and the pipes for the windscreen washer fluid were round the wrong way, button for the front sent it to the rear and vice versa), but they were both simple fixes, and £4k for a 12 month old car with 11k miles was pretty damn good. For the same money at the time I was looking at cars 3-6 years old.

 

As it hadn't reached the age for it's first MOT, a lot of insurance companies wanted to see an engineer's report before giving me a quote, however Adrian Flux gave me a good deal without the need for one.

 

Once it had it's first MOT the premium went down quite a bit as I was able to shop around a lot more. Buying it was obviously a big risk, but when is buying a S/H car not a risk?

Posted
it makes you wonder as ive seen cars under 6 mths old put on cat d for a dented wing and smashed headlight,but nowerdays the owner can refused the car to be repaired and either receive a new car or get full insurance value ,and thats why you look at some for sale and think why have they wrote it off for so little damaged

 

A friend of mines dad runs a business repairing cat C and D cars and commercials...

 

some of the things they get written off for is ridiculous,.....a few cars have only recieved a paint touch up and clean before there sold on....can be very good value :thumbsup:

Posted

when you take a car for a modern mot and they give you the green pass slip there is also an orange coloured one as well, if you read it carefully it will have a box saying it was previously written off.

 

My passat was hit in the side and written off but was then bought by a local garage to me and repaired, i was aware of the work carried out but still bought it as it was well belove book value and even seen the damage prior to repair was ok with it.

 

What you need to check is that you advise your insurance company of its history and check that you will get the proper value of the car as it would be effected if written off in your ownership. What you pay for it and what it will cost to replace it with an identical model of same spec will be big difference.

Posted
it makes you wonder as ive seen cars under 6 mths old put on cat d for a dented wing and smashed headlight,but nowerdays the owner can refused the car to be repaired and either receive a new car or get full insurance value ,and thats why you look at some for sale and think why have they wrote it off for so little damaged

 

Sorry double post

Posted

The problem with modern cars is what seems like a quick fix (like replacing a headlamp) is a day's work! Need a wing, bumper and bonnet and it adds up. Stupid though, it's a reflection of the throw away society.

Posted

for a 20k car to be written off buy the insurance then it must be a big accident. i wouldn't think they would pay the customer £20k when they could repair it for £5k.

 

i'm my opinion, it would have been in a big smash.

Posted
for a 20k car to be written off buy the insurance then it must be a big accident. i wouldn't think they would pay the customer £20k when they could repair it for £5k.

 

i'm my opinion, it would have been in a big smash.

 

My dad's new GS300 was involved in an accident and the repair bill, because it was repaired was around £17,000. The entire rear end was replaced but it looks like new now :mrgreen: .

Posted

A friend of mines dad runs a business repairing cat C and D cars and commercials...

 

some of the things they get written off for is ridiculous,.....a few cars have only recieved a paint touch up and clean before there sold on....can be very good value :thumbsup:

 

Has he any cheap land rover defender 90s ? :mrgreen:

Posted

A friend of mines dad runs a business repairing cat C and D cars and commercials...

 

some of the things they get written off for is ridiculous,.....a few cars have only recieved a paint touch up and clean before there sold on....can be very good value :thumbsup:

 

Has he any cheap land rover defender 90s ? :mrgreen:

 

ill ask mate, hes normally got few decent 4x4s around........bit far away aint ya tho :lol:

Posted

nothing wrong with cat d or c the history of damage is recorded with the dvla so when they are repaired they have to go through a stringent test to be certified roadworthy again obviously those testing the vehicle are aware of the accident history and check the repairs have been made to a safe satisfoctory standard

Posted

some cars are written off because the overall cost of the claim is to high. courtesy cars and solicitors bills are part of the claim. a car may well be econonical to repair but still be written off. ive bought a few over the years and never had a problem. :thumbsup:

Posted

I wouldnt have a problem buying a Cat D car, but you got to take in to mind that one day you will want to sell it, you will have to let the new owner know it Cat.... that where the problem is there a hard sell, if you going to drive it in to the ground then buy one otherwise I wouldnt bother

Posted
nothing wrong with cat d or c the history of damage is recorded with the dvla so when they are repaired they have to go through a stringent test to be certified roadworthy again obviously those testing the vehicle are aware of the accident history and check the repairs have been made to a safe satisfoctory standard

 

My father in law repairs lots of write offs, when he took his first one to be tested (its a fairly new thing to have to do) he was shiting himself thinking they would be inspecting the quality of his repair, all they checked was chassis numbers etc.. to check it hadn't been rung!!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...