Jump to content

what would you rather have, higher bhp or torque?  

39 members have voted

  1. 1. what would you rather have, higher bhp or torque?

    • higher bhp...
      4
    • higher torque...
      29
    • don't give a shit...
      6


Recommended Posts

Posted

hi every one... just got a quick couple of questions... the first is the poll so i will let that do it's job and the second is of a tuning nature....

 

here goes, are there any fundametal methods to tuning that decide whether the engine will gain more hp or torque? one example i know is a 4-2-1 manifold gives better torque and a 4-1 gives better high rpm bhp... but does anyone know anyother (simple pronciples here) tuning 'hypothesis' on getting more torque over horse power?

 

another example i've heard but not sure of the credibility is re. bike carbs and that a longer inlet manifold gives more low down torque?

 

the reason i ask is i wanna get the torque up on my pinto and wondered if there are any golden rules i should follow?

 

cheers

 

rich :mrgreen:

Posted

Cam choice is also a big factor... and bore (e.g. a 2.1 is more torquey than a 2.0 L) but overall it depends what u want from the car. If u going for a fast road build you may want a more torquey cam like the Kent RL31 (this idles nicely, good low down power and perfect for street driving) If u racing at the Pod u might want a bigger bhp cam like the HT1 (not as friendly on the road but gives more top end...

 

:thumbsup:

Posted

[edit] Mechanical horsepower

See History of the term "horsepower"

The term "horsepower" was coined by the engineer James Watt (1736 to 1819) in 1782 while working in the performance of steam engines. This occurred while using a mine pony to lift coal out of a coal mine. He conceived the idea of defining the power exerted by these animals to accomplish this work. He found that, on the average, a mine horse could pull (lift by means of a pulley) 22,000 foot-pounds per minute. Rather than call this "pony" power, he increased these test results by 50 percent, and called it horsepower i.e. 33,000 foot-pounds of work per minute.

 

Assuming the third CGPM (1901, CR 70) definition of standard gravity, g, and the international avoirdupois pound (1958), one mechanical horsepower is:

 

1 hp ≡ 33,000 ft·lbf/min by definition

= 550 ft·lbf/s since 1 min = 60 s

= 550 × 0.3048 × 0.45359237 m·kgf/s since 1 ft = 0.3048 m and

= 76.0402249068 kgf·m/s 1 lb = 0.45359237 kg

= 76.0402249068 × 9.80665 kg·m²/s³ g = 9.80665 m/s²

= 745.69987158227022 W since 1 W ≡ 1 J/s = 1 N·m/s = 1 (kg·m/s²)·(m/s)

 

 

Or given that 1 hp = 550 ft-lb/s, 1 ft = 0.3048 m, 1 lb = 4.448 N, 1 J = 1 N-m, 1 W = 1 J/s: 1 hp = 746 W

 

cross multiply and cancel out:

 

550 ft-lb/s 0.3048 m 4.448 N 1 J 1 W

1 hp 1 ft 1 lb 1 N-m 1 J/s

 

= 745.66272 W or 746 W

Brake horsepower

Brake horsepower (bhp) is the measure of an engine's horsepower without the loss in power caused by the gearbox, generator, differential, water pump, and other auxiliary components such as alternator, power steering, and AC compressor. Thus the prefix "brake" refers to where the power is measured: at the engine's output shaft, as on an engine dynamometer. The actual horsepower delivered to the driving wheels is less. An engine would have to be retested to obtain a rating in another system. The term "brake" refers to the original use of a band brake to measure torque during the test (which is multiplied by the engine RPM and a scaling constant to give horsepower).

Posted
[edit] Mechanical horsepower

See History of the term "horsepower"

The term "horsepower" was coined by the engineer James Watt (1736 to 1819) in 1782 while working in the performance of steam engines. This occurred while using a mine pony to lift coal out of a coal mine. He conceived the idea of defining the power exerted by these animals to accomplish this work. He found that, on the average, a mine horse could pull (lift by means of a pulley) 22,000 foot-pounds per minute. Rather than call this "pony" power, he increased these test results by 50 percent, and called it horsepower i.e. 33,000 foot-pounds of work per minute.

 

Assuming the third CGPM (1901, CR 70) definition of standard gravity, g, and the international avoirdupois pound (1958), one mechanical horsepower is:

 

1 hp ≡ 33,000 ft·lbf/min by definition

= 550 ft·lbf/s since 1 min = 60 s

= 550 × 0.3048 × 0.45359237 m·kgf/s since 1 ft = 0.3048 m and

= 76.0402249068 kgf·m/s 1 lb = 0.45359237 kg

= 76.0402249068 × 9.80665 kg·m²/s³ g = 9.80665 m/s²

= 745.69987158227022 W since 1 W ≡ 1 J/s = 1 N·m/s = 1 (kg·m/s²)·(m/s)

 

 

Or given that 1 hp = 550 ft-lb/s, 1 ft = 0.3048 m, 1 lb = 4.448 N, 1 J = 1 N-m, 1 W = 1 J/s: 1 hp = 746 W

 

cross multiply and cancel out:

 

550 ft-lb/s 0.3048 m 4.448 N 1 J 1 W

1 hp 1 ft 1 lb 1 N-m 1 J/s

 

= 745.66272 W or 746 W

Brake horsepower

Brake horsepower (bhp) is the measure of an engine's horsepower without the loss in power caused by the gearbox, generator, differential, water pump, and other auxiliary components such as alternator, power steering, and AC compressor. Thus the prefix "brake" refers to where the power is measured: at the engine's output shaft, as on an engine dynamometer. The actual horsepower delivered to the driving wheels is less. An engine would have to be retested to obtain a rating in another system. The term "brake" refers to the original use of a band brake to measure torque during the test (which is multiplied by the engine RPM and a scaling constant to give horsepower).

 

blimey, all this on a friday afternoon! thanks for the techi detail but unfortunatly i knew all this from reading a phat document on understanding horse power... what i wana know is how this applies to engine tuning? and why if possible....

like why is a 2.1 more torque than a 2ltr? or like 'will higher compression give me more torque or more bhp?' (obviously it gives both!) i just really wana get my torque up for standing starts...

Posted

2.1 will be more torquey cuz it's got a bigger displacement and thus more rotating mass. Or something.

If it was a 2.1 done via crank stroke and not bore, you'd have even more torque. Don't quite understand why, but that's the way it works.

Guest MK1gaz
Posted

BHP sells engines and torque wins races . You need both and at above 5000 RPM if possible .

Guest MK1gaz
Posted

Turbos , superchargers and nitrous systems make the best torque per litre .

Posted

As people have said, depends what you want out of yer motor.

 

Torque= decent drivability

 

BHP= having to rev it to get anywhere. Which is fun, but can get irritating.

Posted

Big torque wins races. Big horsepower sounds good down the pub but without torque its nothing. Torque is what really gets a car moving off the mark. Thats why i love big V8s loads of tyre shredding torque but when tuned right they make loads of hp up top.

For a road car you want plenty of torque down low coz the engine spends most of its life below 3000rpm. The trick is to build an engine that makes good torque and horsepower.

Posted
2.1 will be more torquey cuz it's got a bigger displacement and thus more rotating mass. Or something.

If it was a 2.1 done via crank stroke and not bore, you'd have even more torque. Don't quite understand why, but that's the way it works.

 

2.1 done by bigger bore standard stroke gives u more hosepower with a slight increase in torque. Basicly the bigger piston can suck more air and fuel in.

2.1 done by longer stroke crank tend to make more torque with less of an increase in horsepower. If you think of the crank as a lever the longer the stroke the more leaverage there is therefore more torque. Though stroker cranks don't like to spin as fast and coz of this they zap a little power up top.

Posted
2.1 will be more torquey cuz it's got a bigger displacement and thus more rotating mass. Or something.

If it was a 2.1 done via crank stroke and not bore, you'd have even more torque. Don't quite understand why, but that's the way it works.

 

2.1 done by bigger bore standard stroke gives u more hosepower with a slight increase in torque. Basicly the bigger piston can suck more air and fuel in.

2.1 done by longer stroke crank tend to make more torque with less of an increase in horsepower. If you think of the crank as a lever the longer the stroke the more leaverage there is therefore more torque. Though stroker cranks don't like to spin as fast and coz of this they zap a little power up top.

 

can you do both - crank and bore ? =2.2 or even better bore out to 2.3 then do the crank, be like 2.5 :twisted:

Posted
Big horsepower sounds good down the pub but without torque its nothing.

 

I'll have to disagree, although it does depend on what you want to use your viehicle for, to decide what is important for you.

 

Bhp is just a calculation of torque & revs, simple as that.

 

If you can get the engine to rev you don't need big torque numbers to get results.

 

If you can get the torque you don't need lots of revs to get results.

 

eg.

 

[torque x revs] / 5252 = Bhp

 

 

65 lb/ft torque @ 20,000 rpm = 247 bhp

 

260 lb/ft torque @ 5000 rpm = 247 bhp

 

Race engines tend to opt for revs, therefore bhp wins races,

 

Torque tows the race car to the track :mrgreen:

Posted
Race engines tend to opt for revs, therefore bhp wins races,

 

Torque tows the race car to the track :mrgreen:

 

cheeky! so, basicly, if i wana get more torque from my pinto, the consensus is to get a longer stroke to increase the bore? anyone know how this affects compression? I'm assuming this will lower the compression, but i have a high comp engine anyway so i uess this wouldn't matter?

 

anyone know if certain carbs or the way they are set up will improve your torque at the sacrefice of some bhp?

 

cheers

Posted

There is a high torque cam available. So if you are after more, opt for that cam and get a 2.1 bottom end.? 38 DGAS carb. bobs your uncle

Posted

id rather have the torque for a neck snapping launch... but then again youd prob snap driveshafts and stuff too

Posted

already got an injection head with a high torque cam and it's been skimmed, mated to a 205 block.... got some bikecarbs to fit but they aren't on yet, but ive been told a longer inlet manifold makes more torque?

 

how much of my hard earned penies would it take to sort the internals to make it a 2.1 bore (via crank & piston trickery, not through a simple re-bore)? i'm guessing a lot... is this the sort of work one could undertake themselves, or is some specialist business required?

Posted
already got an injection head with a high torque cam and it's been skimmed, mated to a 205 block.... got some bikecarbs to fit but they aren't on yet, but ive been told a longer inlet manifold makes more torque?

 

how much of my hard earned penies would it take to sort the internals to make it a 2.1 bore (via crank & piston trickery, not through a simple re-bore)? i'm guessing a lot... is this the sort of work one could undertake themselves, or is some specialist business required?

 

Good fun subject mate.

 

What I would recommend is tell us your budget, and what you want to use the car for, then we could recommend your best parts, Fiesta Steve is right but an engine at 20,000 rpms wont be very usable in the tesco car park. If you increase your capacity you will increase your torque. A good head job and matching cam will also increase your power and torque probably by more than a stroke / over bore will achieve, your inlet tract length wants to match your cam and exhaust design, so a "longer the better" wont necessarily be right unless they know your set up. Big subject mate.

 

Best anallagy of Power V Torque I've read is.

 

Torque - How much you get paid

Power - How often you get paid.

 

If you got a really long bar and pulled on the end of it (torque) you would be able to stop your engine, say 1lb on the end of a 100ft bar (100ft /lbs), but you don't make enough power to go very fast!!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...