omj624p Posted January 10, 2010 Report Posted January 10, 2010 That you cant defend youself in your own home http://news.sky.com/skynews/Home/Showbi ... _Teenagers ''It came amid calls for greater rights for people to defend themselves against intruders on their property. In December, Munir Hussain was jailed for attacking a man who tied up his family in their home. He and his brother used a cricket bat to beat one of the intruders.'' I wonder how many of us would just sit by and let someone do anything to our families - I think we'd all end up in prison
Trevmk3 Posted January 10, 2010 Report Posted January 10, 2010 it is crap isnt it. if someone got into our house i think they would have a fight on there hands and i would probably get arrested and sent down for longer than they would. when my dad was in hospital before he died some youths were throwing clumps of grass (pulled out the ground with the mud holding it together) at the house and windows so me and my brother both tooled up from the shed and chased the little bastards away, they didnt come back did hurt them or catch them but it would of sent fear through there bodies as 2 6ft + lads chased them up the road
GJUK Posted January 10, 2010 Report Posted January 10, 2010 Bloody disgusting. Makes my shit itch. Yeah I don't like her much either. If some youths jumped in to my garden they'd be getting chased by 6 boxer dogs. Peace. Jon
over_head_cam Posted January 10, 2010 Report Posted January 10, 2010 That's the one thing that I think the Americans have over us. They can defend themselves in their homes (on on their property) I watched something where a bloke went out and shot a burglar and walked away scott free. I'm not saying we should go round shooting everybody, but I know for a fact that some scumbag will have a big problem if I find him in my house - "I think he fell down the stairs officer"
RossMK2 Posted January 10, 2010 Report Posted January 10, 2010 the reason that we have all the young people that think they are above everyone is because they know if they smash a window of someones house or smash a car up they can't get hurt themselves. if you could defend yourself, property and your belongings these people would be droped down a peg or too i know this happens cause i know people at school
Admin Vista Posted January 10, 2010 Admin Report Posted January 10, 2010 But don't you think there has to be a difference between defending yourself against somebody in your home and beating the living crap out of someone AFTER they've the left your home? The former I would agree should be allowed and is completely justified, the latter is nothing more than a revenge attack / vigilantism and that is definitely not the same thing. Let’s take the cases of Munir Hussain and the other High Profile one, Tony Martin the farmer that was jailed for shooting dead an intruder. In my opinion both of these people DESERVED to go to jail because they went WAY beyond defending themselves in their home. Tony Martin shot him in the back and killed the burglar AFTER he’d left his house and was therefore no longer a threat to him. Ergo revenge. Munir Hussain also went way beyond defending his home when he and an accomplice chased the offender down the street and beat him senseless with a cricket bat. As they had left his home they were clearly no longer a threat to him and so his actions were again motivated by revenge, especially as clearly between the two of them they could have restrained the offender until the proper law enforcement agencies arrived. Read the article at this link and tell me it wasn't revenge motivated when they beat him round the head so hard he has permanent brain damage http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/u ... 956044.ece So, defending yourself in your home against uninvited guests? Yes that gets my full support and no-one should be prosecuted for doing so. But vigilantism and beating the crap out of people to get even? I’ll leave that to criminals.
omj624p Posted January 10, 2010 Author Report Posted January 10, 2010 So, defending yourself in your home against uninvited guests? Yes that gets my full support and no-one should be prosecuted for doing so. But vigilantism and beating the crap out of people to get even? I’ll leave that to criminals. I have to agree 100% with that. I admit I didnt know the full story about Munir Hussain when I posted, but that wasnt the point I was making.
sambo Posted January 10, 2010 Report Posted January 10, 2010 But don't you think there has to be a difference between defending yourself against somebody in your home and beating the living crap out of someone AFTER they've the left your home? The former I would agree should be allowed and is completely justified, the latter is nothing more than a revenge attack / vigilantism and that is definitely not the same thing. Let’s take the cases of Munir Hussain and the other High Profile one, Tony Martin the farmer that was jailed for shooting dead an intruder. In my opinion both of these people DESERVED to go to jail because they went WAY beyond defending themselves in their home. Tony Martin shot him in the back and killed the burglar AFTER he’d left his house and was therefore no longer a threat to him. Ergo revenge. Munir Hussain also went way beyond defending his home when he and an accomplice chased the offender down the street and beat him senseless with a cricket bat. As they had left his home they were clearly no longer a threat to him and so his actions were again motivated by revenge, especially as clearly between the two of them they could have restrained the offender until the proper law enforcement agencies arrived. Read the article at this link and tell me it wasn't revenge motivated when they beat him round the head so hard he has permanent brain damage http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/u ... 956044.ece So, defending yourself in your home against uninvited guests? Yes that gets my full support and no-one should be prosecuted for doing so. But vigilantism and beating the crap out of people to get even? I’ll leave that to criminals. I do agree with you Scott but to be fair, if some bonehead broke into my house, threatened my family and managed to get out... i would run them down and beat the living crap out of them. Revenge...... fook yes. It is a dish best served cold........... with a cricket bat.
PIG Posted January 10, 2010 Report Posted January 10, 2010 i also agree with scott to a point but the real truth about it is if some fairy breaks in to my house with my misses and kids there,run or not i would kick the fook out of them.FACT dont break in to my house
Admin Vista Posted January 10, 2010 Admin Report Posted January 10, 2010 That's fine Sam you accept your actions are revenge motivated so just be prepared to do the time for the crime and don't appear all innocent on the news. Which is how the media portrayed Munir Hussein in an effort to sensationalise his case and increase their circulation.
YOUNGY Posted January 10, 2010 Report Posted January 10, 2010 i've got a baseball bat by my bed and a baseball bat behind the chair near the front door, they are there 24/7 if anyone comes in their getting it if the dogs don't get them first. Fook the law my property i pay for it i protect it.
Posse Posted January 10, 2010 Report Posted January 10, 2010 i also agree with scott to a point but the real truth about it is if some fairy breaks in to my house with my misses and kids there,run or not i would kick the fook out of them.FACT dont break in to my house pig ...
caprinerd Posted January 10, 2010 Report Posted January 10, 2010 i agree with the in your own home comment and as for the running them down and knocking ten barrels out of them, i think everyone would want to do that, but if you did do that then expect to do the time for it, a vigilanty attack is not legal in the states but if on your property it then becomes restraint as long as a person isnt beaten half to death, we live in a nanny state and the kids and adult criminals know this and can work the system to their own bennifit, not right but true
omj624p Posted January 10, 2010 Author Report Posted January 10, 2010 If we're talking about protecting your property, what if someone steals your car, and you chase them (in another car) and catch up with them?
Posse Posted January 10, 2010 Report Posted January 10, 2010 If we're talking about protecting your property, what if someone steals your car, and you chase them (in another car) and catch up with them? I would of thought it would be like the police do steve you would have to hold back just in case he crashed otherwise you would prob get in the shit for making them speed and crash?
RossMK2 Posted January 10, 2010 Report Posted January 10, 2010 they would have an headache before they left the drive
mk1super Posted January 10, 2010 Report Posted January 10, 2010 Someone breaks into your home, or steals your car, or anything else you have bust your ass for, they should be hung from the nearest lampost as a warning onto others.
bigglesmk2 Posted January 10, 2010 Report Posted January 10, 2010 Im a nice guy ,i live in a nice area have nice things and work hard for all of it but i grew up in slums and have allways kept a baseball bat under my bed. I rather have it and not need it then to need it and not have it
wetandwindy3 Posted January 10, 2010 Report Posted January 10, 2010 i also agree with scott to a point but the real truth about it is if some fairy breaks in to my house with my misses and kids there,run or not i would kick the fook out of them.FACT dont break in to my house would agree with pig on this one
sambo Posted January 11, 2010 Report Posted January 11, 2010 That's fine Sam you accept your actions are revenge motivated so just be prepared to do the time for the crime and don't appear all innocent on the news. Which is how the media portrayed Munir Hussein in an effort to sensationalise his case and increase their circulation. Seriously though. Think about it. Someone has just held a knife to your wifes throat or threatened your kids with a knife. Then runs off. You manage to catch up with them.... its human nature to want revenge and to make them pay for doing that. If you wouldnt do the same, if this happened to you and you could them spend 5 minuite in a room with them, and you wouldnt want to physically hurt them, you are not right. Some arrogant fooking bonehead threatening my family...... i'd kick thier arse into next week given half a chance. I'd go all Charlse Bronson on thier arse.
Admin Vista Posted January 11, 2010 Admin Report Posted January 11, 2010 I am thinking about it Sam, I'm thinking about going to jail and missing the most important years of my 15 month old sons young life and leaving my wife to cope all on her own with no income from me to support them. Ok, finished thinking about it and no, much as I'd want to have my revenge, I wouldn't.
sambo Posted January 11, 2010 Report Posted January 11, 2010 I am thinking about it Sam, I'm thinking about going to jail and missing the most important years of my 15 month old sons young life and leaving my wife to cope all on her own with no income from me to support them. Ok, finished thinking about it and no, much as I'd want to have my revenge, I wouldn't. I see what your saying but, it would be very hard to resist kicking the crap out of the guy who held your family at knife point. I know i wouldnt be thinking rationally!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now